Research takes time to develop. Drawing on a conversation with UCL’s Graeme Reid, Dr Pınar Şengül argues that governments should account for the disruption caused by reform and give effective policies time to work.
Research takes time to develop. Drawing on a conversation with UCL’s Graeme Reid, Dr Pınar Şengül argues that governments should account for the disruption caused by reform and give effective policies time to work.
A research project may take a decade to mature. During that time, the institutions funding it can be reorganised, priorities rewritten and programmes replaced. We should ask more of science policy than a succession of new initiatives. It should offer researchers a dependable basis on which to plan.
When I interviewed Professor Graeme Reid, Professor of Science and Research Policy at UCL, he identified frequent policy change as a structural problem for British science. “Policymakers need to recognise the benefits of stability,” he told me. “At the moment, they seem to put too much weight on change.”
His comparison was deliberately illustrative: a project might take five to ten years to move from conception to its next stage, while policy could change every two years. Those are not fixed averages across science. They expose a question that deserves a place in every proposed reform: will the arrangements supporting research last long enough to do their job?
Giving policy time to work
Regional innovation policy offers a useful example. Reid describes a broadly enduring ambition to use research to support economic growth across the UK. Yet, in his account, responsibility for delivering it has repeatedly moved between government structures, accompanied by new funding instruments. The objective can remain familiar while the means of pursuing it keep changing.
“Just when some arrangements get going, they are abolished and replaced by something with the same purpose but a different structure,” he said.
That observation should change how we judge reform. A new structure needs to justify the disruption involved in replacing the old one. For a university trying to sustain a regional partnership, the relevant questions include who will fund the next stage and whether the relationship can survive a reorganisation. Announcing a successor programme does not, by itself, answer them.
Continuity must remain open to scrutiny. Ineffective policies should be improved or ended, and emerging fields may need different forms of support. But governments should explain what has failed, what evidence supports the replacement and how existing work will continue during the transition. Stability should be assessed alongside the expected benefits of change.
What Horizon Europe can tell us
The UK’s association with Horizon Europe, which began on 1 January 2024, illustrates the value of established arrangements for international research. Reid emphasises the advantage of joining a community whose members have already agreed much of the basis for collaboration. Researchers can find partners and build projects on familiar terms.
That is a substantial benefit. It also has limits as a measure of national success. “I do not think you can correlate association with Horizon Europe with the overall state of research and innovation in the UK,” Reid said. “There are too many other variables.”
I think that distinction is essential to an honest debate about British science. Participation in a major programme cannot tell us, on its own, whether the wider system is healthy. We need evidence about how collaborations work, what researchers can sustain and where difficulties persist. A change in formal status cannot settle all those questions.
The costs deserve the same attention. Reid points out that EU membership made the benefits of research collaboration directly visible to scientists, while the cost sat within the UK’s wider membership contribution. His account raises a continuing policy question about where the financial burden of association should fall. A durable commitment to collaboration requires clarity about how that commitment will be funded.
Recognising value across generations
The case for continuity becomes stronger when we consider what governments expect research to deliver. “Research delivers impact every day,” Reid said. “It will deliver impact this afternoon, although that impact may come from work done ten or twenty years ago.”
A useful discovery does not arrive with a timetable that matches a spending announcement. Reid describes research as an ecosystem in which engagement with the frontiers of knowledge helps people recognise and use opportunities arising from earlier work. In that account, present research capacity matters even when the knowledge being applied is decades old.
For me, this is a reason to question demands that every project demonstrate an immediate economic return. We should ask how support for research sustains the ability to understand and use discoveries over time. A narrow assessment can overlook the people and expertise needed to turn an earlier finding into something useful.
Reid’s discussion of university links with business makes the point concrete. He suggests that the movement of graduates and PhD researchers into companies may be the largest form of technology transfer. Their knowledge can be valuable even when it is difficult to capture in financial indicators. Measures focused on easily counted transactions risk missing that contribution.
He also distinguishes the creation of university spinouts from the conditions those companies need to grow. In his view, enabling successful spinouts to become large businesses is a challenge for capital markets that universities cannot solve alone. Policy should be precise about which part of that process it is trying to improve, and give the relevant support time to take effect.
These observations point towards a practical standard for reform. Before replacing a research policy, governments should set out the problem they intend to solve, the period over which improvement can reasonably be assessed and the arrangements for protecting work already under way. An evaluation timetable should reflect the activity being supported.
Reid’s advice to policymakers was simple: “Don’t change policy too often.” Taking it seriously would mean making continuity part of how policy is designed and judged. Researchers should have to adapt to what their investigations reveal. They should also be able to make credible plans for the years those investigations require.
About the author
Dr Pınar Şengül is a neuroscientist and neuropsychologist who received her PhD in Neuroscience from Acıbadem Mehmet Ali Aydınlar University in Istanbul, where her doctoral research applied NMR-based quantitative metabolomics to cerebrospinal fluid and serum in multiple sclerosis. Her work spans clinical biomarkers and neuroinflammatory and neurodegenerative diseases. She is lead author of a 2025 targeted ¹H-NMR serum metabolomics study in possible early-stage multiple sclerosis published in the Journal of Molecular Neuroscience, and of the 2026 International Journal of Molecular Sciences paper, “Serum Metabolomic Profiling Across Five Oligoclonal Band (OCB) Patterns: A Targeted ¹H-NMR Study in Serum.” Since completing her PhD in Neuroscience, she has been working as a freelance science journalist, interviewing scientists from around the world, particularly neuroscientists. She is also a member of the Deutscher Fachjournalisten-Verband (DFJV), an association based in Berlin.
Read also
- After the Grant: What Happens to EU-Funded Innovation Next?
- UK seeking to ‘fully associate’ with EU research after Brexit
- ‘No-deal’ Brexit could mean many researchers in the UK losing crucial funding
- Does the future of European research cross Horizon Europe?
- Universities call on EU to increase spending on scientific research
This post is also available in: DE